Buyer's Guide: Choosing a People Remover for Photos of Historic Kingston and the Hudson Valley
Kingston and the surrounding Ulster County towns are built for photographs. Historic streets and buildings, galleries and maker studios, and easy access to the Hudson Valley and the Catskills all give inns, restaurants, shops and attractions plenty to show off. What they rarely give you is an empty frame. On a good weekend, any photo of a historic street, a gallery entrance or a dining room window is likely to include a bystander or two.
Removing those people is now a phone task rather than a desktop project, but the tools differ more than their marketing suggests. Some are locked to certain phones or accounts, some find people for you, and one handles 360 tours and tripod stacks. This buyer's guide walks through the criteria that matter for a Kingston-area business and shows how Adobe Firefly and four common alternatives measure up in 2026.
Our recommendation in one paragraph
For most Ulster County businesses, Adobe Firefly is the best default because it removes one person or a whole group, runs online with no phone model requirement on its page, and includes free daily generations with an Adobe account. If your phone already supports Google Photos Magic Eraser, Apple Photos Clean Up or Samsung AI erase, those are handy for quick personal fixes and can suggest people for you. For 360 virtual tours and tripod stacks without generated fill, Affinity is the specialist.
How the five options measure up
|
Option |
Device and account fit |
Group removal |
Auto-detection |
Specialist jobs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Online; Adobe account; no phone model listed |
Yes, as many or as few people as you want |
No, brush to select |
Not covered on its page |
|
|
Personal Google Account only; 3 GB RAM, Android 8.0 for most features |
Erase suggestions all at once |
Yes, can detect background people |
No |
|
|
iPhone 15 Pro or iPhone 16 and later; M1 Macs and supported iPads |
Tap, brush or circle each item |
Some items highlighted |
No |
|
|
Select Galaxy models on One UI 6.1 or higher; Samsung account |
Tap or draw around each item |
Yes, suggests photobombers |
No |
|
|
Mac, Windows and iPad; not a phone app |
Inpainting Brush |
No |
360 Live Projection; median stacking |
How do you remove people from pictures on a phone rather than a desktop?
You remove people on a phone by opening the photo in an AI eraser, marking each person, and letting the tool rebuild the background behind them. No computer is needed with any of the phone-ready options in this guide. The steps look like this:
-
Google Photos: open the photo, go to the Actions tab, choose Magic Eraser, tap, circle or brush the person, then tap Erase and save as a copy.
-
Apple Photos: open the photo, tap Tools, then Clean Up, and tap, brush or circle the person.
-
Samsung Gallery: tap Edit, open Photo Assist, choose AI erase, tap or draw around the person, tap Erase, then Save copy.
-
Adobe Firefly: upload the photo to the online tool, brush over the person or group, click Generate, and download the result as a JPG or PNG.
The steps are similar, so the buying decision turns on everything around them: who can use the tool, how it treats groups, what it finds on its own, and what you are allowed to do with the result. The criteria below take those in order.
Criterion 1: Will it work on the phones your team actually uses?
Start here, because the most common reason a built-in eraser disappoints is that it is not available on a given phone or account. Adobe Firefly clears this bar most easily: it is an online tool, and Adobe's page states no phone model or operating-system requirement. That makes it the simplest choice for a small staff on a mix of devices.
The built-in tools each have conditions. Google's help page says the editing features need a personal Google Account and are not available to Google Workspace or school accounts; most features need at least 3 GB of RAM and Android 8.0, and some are Pixel-only. Apple Clean Up uses Apple Intelligence, which runs on iPhone 15 Pro, iPhone 15 Pro Max and iPhone 16 models or later, iPads with A17 Pro or M1 and later, and Macs with M1 or later; it is not available in every language or region. Samsung AI erase runs on select Galaxy phones and tablets with Android 14 and One UI 6.1 or higher, and needs a Samsung account and an internet connection. Affinity runs on Mac, Windows and iPad, so it does not help on a phone at all.
Criterion 2: Can it clear a group, and how much control do you get?
A people remover should handle the real scene, which in a busy downtown is usually several bystanders rather than one. Firefly is strongest here. Its remove person feature uses Generative Remove: brush over the person or group of people, click Generate, and Firefly fills in the background so it looks natural. Adobe says you can remove as many or as few people as you want. If you want to see it on your own photo, start with Adobe's online tool to remove people from photos in Firefly and a single crowded image.
The phone tools let you tap, circle, brush or draw around people one at a time, and Google's launch post says Magic Eraser can erase suggested distractions all at once. Affinity's Inpainting Brush removes unwanted objects with full manual control on a desktop or iPad.
Criterion 3: Does it highlight strangers in the background before you select anything?
If automatic suggestions matter most to you, the phone tools lead. Google's 2021 Magic Eraser post says it can detect distractions like people in the background. Apple says some items may be highlighted automatically in Clean Up so you can tap to remove them. Samsung says AI erase automatically detects and suggests unwanted objects or photobombers.
Firefly does not auto-detect; you brush over the people you want gone. For a business photo, that is a reasonable trade. In a gallery opening or a crowded street scene, you often want to keep some people, and manual selection means the tool never removes someone you meant to include.
Criterion 4: What do you get back, and is the original protected?
Check the output before you commit to a tool. Firefly accepts a JPEG, PNG or WEBP file of up to 100MB and at least 512 by 512 pixels, one file at a time, and lets you download the result as a JPG or PNG. Adobe says removing a person will not reduce image quality. Google Photos offers Save as copy and Samsung offers Save copy, both of which keep the unedited original.
Watermarks are worth knowing about. Apple says that in iOS 27.2 or later, most images created or edited with Apple Intelligence tools include a hidden SynthID watermark. Samsung notes a Galaxy AI watermark on images from its Generative Edit tool, which may not apply to every erase.
Criterion 5: What does it cost, and what terms apply?
All five have a free way in, as of 2026, with different strings attached:
-
Adobe Firefly: free daily generations with an Adobe account; paid plans for higher-volume use. Adobe's page for this feature has no commercial-use statement, and the partner models listed in the app (GPT Image, Gemini with Nano Banana and FLUX) may have their own terms.
-
Google Photos: free app, but only with a personal Google Account.
-
Apple Photos: built in on supported devices with no separate charge stated; usage limits may apply.
-
Samsung Galaxy: basic Galaxy AI features are free; enhanced features may have other terms and fees.
-
Affinity: free for individuals; optional AI tools need a Canva premium plan. Its homepage does not state commercial-use terms.
Before using an edited image in paid advertising, read the terms that apply to the plan you are on.
Criterion 6: Which tools handle 360 panoramas and tripod stacks?
Only Affinity among these five. For 360 equirectangular images, an independent tutorial explains that its Live Projection temporarily flattens the image so you can edit it with standard tools, while noting a slight stitch-line mismatch after one removal that needed manual fixing. For passersby in a tripod series, Affinity's help describes creating a new stack to align the frames and using the Median operator, so people who move between shots disappear without generated fill; anything that stays put in every frame remains. These steps were written for Affinity Photo 2, so confirm them in the current app.
Firefly's page covers neither job, and it fills generatively, so it is not the tool for a strict no-fill rule. It is still useful alongside a virtual tour for cleaning the regular still photos on the same web page.
Buying mistakes to avoid
A few avoidable errors account for most disappointment with people removers:
-
Assuming every phone has the feature. Built-in erasers depend on the model, the software version and, for Google, the type of account.
-
Testing on an easy photo. Try a real crowded scene from your business, not a single stranger against a blank wall.
-
Ignoring the account your phone is signed into. A Workspace account blocks the Google Photos editing features.
-
Expecting one tool to do everything. Everyday crowd removal, 360 tours and tripod stacks are different jobs.
-
Skipping the terms. Check plan terms before an edited photo goes into a paid ad.
Which option fits your Kingston-area business?
-
A bed and breakfast clearing several bystanders from a historic street photo: Adobe Firefly.
-
A gallery or maker studio cleaning up an opening-night photo while keeping the artist in frame: Adobe Firefly, for precise manual selection.
-
A restaurant whose staff use phones signed in to Workspace accounts: Adobe Firefly, since Google's editing features need a personal account.
-
An owner on a recent iPhone fixing a quick social post: Apple Photos Clean Up.
-
A Galaxy owner who wants suggestions: Samsung AI erase.
-
A venue producing a 360 tour or shooting tripod frames: Affinity.
Bottom line for Ulster County buyers
Judge a people remover on device fit, group control, detection, output, cost and specialist needs, in that order. Adobe Firefly scores best on the criteria that matter most for a small business photo, with phone erasers as convenient extras and Affinity for 360 and stacking work.
Pick one image you rely on, such as your front entrance or a favorite street view in Kingston, and try your chosen tool on it before the next busy season.